High Courts and Economic Governance in Argentina and Brazil
$95.00 ( ) USD
- Author: Diana Kapiszewski, University of California, Irvine
Adobe eBook Reader
Other available formats:
Looking for an examination copy?
If you are interested in the title for your course we can consider offering an examination copy. To register your interest please contact firstname.lastname@example.org providing details of the course you are teaching.
High Courts and Economic Governance in Argentina and Brazil analyzes how high courts and elected leaders in Latin America interacted over neoliberal restructuring, one of the most significant socioeconomic transformations in recent decades. Courts face a critical choice when deciding cases concerning national economic policy, weighing rule of law concerns against economic imperatives. Elected leaders confront equally difficult dilemmas when courts issue decisions challenging their actions. Based on extensive fieldwork in Argentina and Brazil, this study identifies striking variation in inter-branch interactions between the two countries. In Argentina, while high courts often defer to politicians in the economic realm, inter-branch relations are punctuated by tense bouts of conflict. Brazilian courts and elected officials, by contrast, routinely accommodate one another in their decisions about economic policy. Diana Kapiszewski argues that the two high courts’ contrasting characters – political in Argentina and statesman-like in Brazil – shaped their decisions on controversial cases and conditioned how elected leaders responded to their rulings, channeling inter-branch interactions into persistent patterns.Read more
- Examines both judicial decision-making and elected leaders' compliance with Court rulings, while most studies of comparative judicial politics in Latin America examine only the former
- Cross-national comparison
- Employs an original, systematic case selection technique
Reviews & endorsements
“This is a wonderful book – meticulously crafted, with close attention to methods and concept formation, presenting a nuanced and persuasive argument. Kapiszewski’s analysis places the strategic calculus of courts within their historical and institutional contexts, ultimately producing an account that feels more true to the way judges actually decide and the way politicians interact with their courts. Her argument incorporates what is unique about courts as legal institutions, while remaining fully political in its analysis. An excellent addition to the burgeoning comparative judicial politics literature.” – Daniel M. Brinks, University of Texas, AustinSee more reviews
“A fascinating, methodologically astute, and theoretically sophisticated book. Kapiszewski’s comparative account of high court–elected branch interaction in Brazil and Argentina provides a textbook illustration of how quality political science scholarship is essential to our understanding of law and courts.” – Ran Hirschl, University of Toronto
“Empirically rich and theoretically generative, this study marks a significant advance for the literature on comparative judicial politics. By contrasting patterns over time in two important cases, Kapiszewski gives us a new framework for thinking about judicial interaction with political branches. A major achievement.” – Tom Ginsburg, University of Chicago
“High Courts and Economic Governance in Argentina and Brazil is an important empirical and theoretical contribution to the burgeoning literature on judicial politics in Latin America and to the broader literature on historical institutionalism. Diana Kapiszewski shows that high courts developed identifiable, relatively stable characters that help explain the pattern of interactions between courts and elected officials. By emphasizing court character, she challenges accounts that focus exclusively on judges’ or politicians’ short-term strategic incentives. Kapiszewski also skillfully analyzes the origins of the differences in court character in Argentina and Brazil.” – Scott Mainwaring, Eugene and Helen Conley Professor of Political Science, University of Notre Dame
Not yet reviewed
Be the first to review
Review was not posted due to profanity×
- Date Published: September 2012
- format: Adobe eBook Reader
- isbn: 9781139558075
- contains: 3 b/w illus. 8 tables
- availability: This ISBN is for an eBook version which is distributed on our behalf by a third party.
Table of Contents
1. High court-elected branch institutions in Latin America
2. Setting the scene: Latin America's triple transition and the judicialization of economic governance
3. Politicization and the political court in Argentina
4. Professionalism and the statesman court in Brazil
5. The political court and high court submission and inter-branch confrontation in Argentina
6. The statesman court and inter-branch accommodation in Brazil
7. Conclusions and implications.
Find resources associated with this titleYour search for '' returned .
Type Name Unlocked * Format Size
This title is supported by one or more locked resources. Access to locked resources is granted exclusively by Cambridge University Press to instructors whose faculty status has been verified. To gain access to locked resources, instructors should sign in to or register for a Cambridge user account.
Please use locked resources responsibly and exercise your professional discretion when choosing how you share these materials with your students. Other instructors may wish to use locked resources for assessment purposes and their usefulness is undermined when the source files (for example, solution manuals or test banks) are shared online or via social networks.
Supplementary resources are subject to copyright. Instructors are permitted to view, print or download these resources for use in their teaching, but may not change them or use them for commercial gain.
If you are having problems accessing these resources please contact email@example.com.
Sorry, this resource is locked