States of Emergency in Liberal Democracies
- Author: Nomi Claire Lazar, Graduate School of Public and International Affairs, University of Ottawa
In an emergency, statesmen concentrate power and suspend citizens' rights. These emergency powers are ubiquitous in the crisis government of liberal democracies, but their nature and justification is poorly understood. Based on a pluralist conception of political ethics and political power, this book shows how we can avoid the dangers and confusions inherent in the norm/exception approach that dominates both historical and contemporary debate. The book shows how liberal values need never - indeed must never - be suspended, even in times of urgency. Only then can accountability remain a live possibility. But at the same time, emergency powers can sometimes be justified with reference to extra-liberal norms that also operate in times of normalcy. By emphasizing the continuity between times of normalcy and emergency, the book illuminates the norms of crisis government, broadening our understanding of liberal democratic government and of political ethics in the process.Read more
- Unlike most similar scholarship, the book begins from the assumption that the problem cannot be understood unless it takes into account all elements
- Most US discussions of emergency powers center on the American case, whereas this book has a broader scope than most others available
- Provides a novel approach to subjects subsidiary to emergency powers, particularly the epistemological foundations of liberalism and Roman dictatorship
Reviews & endorsements
'There are few problems more important in the present constitutional universe than those surrounding the notion of 'emergency powers'. Nomi Lazar has written an outstanding book, with particularly helpful analyses both of the Roman dictatorship and of the thought of the most important theorist of the consequences of emergencies, Carl Schmitt. It deserves wide readership and discussion.' Sanford Levinson, University of Texas at AustinSee more reviews
'Challenging theorists who contend that emergencies require the suspension of ordinary legality and theorists who contend that liberal theory cannot tolerate deviations from ordinary legality even during emergencies, Nomi Claire Lazar integrates emergencies into a pluralist liberalism, in which informal norms and especially politics of an ordinary sort regulate the exercise of power during emergencies. Her thoughtful and provocative thesis is an important contribution to scholarship on emergencies and liberalism.' Mark Tushnet, Harvard Law School
'This important and timely work argues that emergency powers should not be regarded as 'exceptions' from norms, but rather should be understood as continuous with the normative structure in liberal democracies. Lazar takes issue both with 'norm/exception' dichotomists who leave emergency powers morally unmoored, and with those liberals who reject their use even at the risk of state collapse. Instead, Lazar forcefully demonstrates that emergency powers can be compatible with liberal democracies, insofar as these regimes recognize order as a fundamental value in society and accept quotidian rights derogations for its sake. Drawing on historical examples, classic works in political thought, and contemporary legal and political theory, States of Emergency in Liberal Democracies is essential reading for scholars interested in the nature and institutional form of emergency powers.' Melissa Schwartzberg, Columbia University
'The book encourages us to actively discuss and evaluate emergencies and the use of emergency powers on both an ex ante and an ex post facto basis.' Redescriptions
Not yet reviewed
Be the first to review
Review was not posted due to profanity×
- Date Published: September 2009
- format: Adobe eBook Reader
- isbn: 9780511590535
- availability: This ISBN is for an eBook version which is distributed on our behalf by a third party.
Table of Contents
1. The problem of emergency
2. Must exceptionalism prove the rule?
3. Two concepts of liberalism
4. Are rights derogations always wrong?
5. The rule of law and the Roman dictatorship
6. The norms of crisis government.
Sorry, this resource is locked
Please register or sign in to request access. If you are having problems accessing these resources please email firstname.lastname@example.orgRegister Sign in